<em>Will Trent</em> has undergone significant transformation from its original novels, and this evolution has been largely beneficial for fans of the series. One of the most pressing mysteries lingering from Will Trent season 3 is the potential rekindling of Will and Angie’s romance now that she is expecting a child with another man. Readers of the book series are aware that the original storyline leads Will to a different romantic partner, who may be introduced in Will Trent season 4. However, the ongoing tension between Will and Angie, characterized by a “will they/won’t they” dynamic, represents just one of many departures from the source material.

Numerous differences between the novels and the television adaptation are evident, particularly concerning character portrayals. While Betty’s character remains relatively unchanged, the rest of the Will Trent ensemble bears little resemblance to their book counterparts. Originally, Will was depicted as a tall blonde character, often compared to Lurch from The Addams Family, a variation that book enthusiasts have generally accepted more readily than fans of Jack Reacher did when Tom Cruise was cast in that role. However, these character modifications are relatively minor when considering the extensive alterations ABC made to the overall tone of the original novels.

The Gripping Darkness of Karin Slaughter’s Will Trent Books Compared to the ABC Series

The First Book Sets a Chilling Tone from the Start

While Ormewood’s tumor and Goodwin’s injury represent dark elements in the Will Trent season 3 finale, they pale in comparison to the intense bleakness found within Karin Slaughter’s novels. The inaugural book, Triptych, opens with a horrifying scene where Michael Ormewood investigates the brutal death of a prostitute who choked on her own blood after enduring a vicious assault that left her tongue severed on the stairway of her housing project. Even with Ormewood’s harrowing experiences witnessing a school full of women perishing in flames during the Gulf War, this particular scene is gruesome enough to deeply disturb him.

The plot thickens further when Ormewood encounters Will, who discloses that the victim, Aleesha Monroe, is involved in a GBI investigation concerning similar heinous cases. The shocking twist is that, despite being in her 30s, Aleesha is significantly older than the other rape victims, all of whom suffered similar brutal fates, with their tongues bitten off. Most of these victims were around the same age as Ormewood’s young mistress, who had just turned 15 when the narrative begins. To make matters even more heart-wrenching, Will elaborates on a comparable crime involving a 10-year-old girl, despite failing to find any connection between her and the ongoing case.

ABC’s Will Trent Balances Dark Themes with Humor Perfectly for Broadcast Television

The Series’ Unique Humor Provides a Refreshing Contrast to Dark Themes

For viewers who find the raw intensity of the early chapters in the novels overwhelming, the ABC adaptation lightens the mood significantly. For instance, while Ormewood’s character maintains a level of moral decency by engaging with women closer to his age, graphic violence is seldom depicted or described in disturbing detail, which contrasts sharply with the original novels. One of the most commendable aspects of the series is its ability to juxtapose the darker elements of Will Trent’s GBI investigations with moments of levity, often transforming grim scenarios into comedic relief.

In one of the most impactful moments of the series, Will inadvertently shoots a child, a tragic event that resonates deeply with audiences. This scenario, while plausible for a network drama, is not as severe as some incidents portrayed in Law & Order: SVU. However, it is rare for a series—except perhaps dark comedies like BoJack Horseman—to depict a protagonist grappling with guilt through surreal, drug-induced hallucinations featuring upbeat musical numbers. While such high-concept elements may not align with the novels’ tone, they serve to set Will Trent apart from many other procedural dramas.

The Case for a Darker Adaptation of Will Trent for Streaming Platforms

Understanding the Implications of a Darker Adaptation

Several of the distinctions between Will Trent and its source material could be moderated just enough to be suitable for network television; however, an authentic adaptation of the novels would likely be inappropriate for conventional broadcast due to the severe tone of Slaughter’s writing. Her exploration of the pervasive cynicism within law enforcement and the boundless potential for human malevolence would challenge even darker series like AMC’s The Killing. Nevertheless, it raises the question of whether the show’s prestige would truly benefit from transitioning to a streaming platform.

Certain narrative choices, such as telling a significant portion of Triptych from the viewpoint of a man convicted of raping and murdering his childhood best friend, could create an intriguing binge-worthy experience. However, a darker version of Will Trent suitable for streaming would likely face challenges, such as an unpredictable release schedule and potentially fewer episodes per season. The source material provides a captivating read for those who can handle its darker themes, but the more approachable version currently airing on network television offers a significantly more enjoyable experience.

Enjoy ScreenRant’s primetime coverage? Click below to sign up for our weekly Network TV newsletter (make sure to check “Network TV” in your preferences) and get the inside scoop from actors and showrunners on your favorite series.

SIGN UP NOW