Theresa Nist and Gerry Turner, The Golden Bachelor Season 1

Length of Marriage: Three months before divorce filing

He and She Said: It turns out the Journey-loving couple wasn’t willing to take the midnight train going anywhere. After sharing plans to move to South Carolina, Jersey girl Theresa and Indiana-based Gerry revealed in April 2024 that they couldn’t agree on a home base and were divorcing three months after their TV wedding.

As Gerry explained on Good Morning America, “We look at these situations and I think we just feel like it’s best for the happiness of each of us to live apart.”

Theresa agreed, stating, “We never got to the point where we made that decision.”

However, she later confessed this wasn’t the only factor.

“It’s not just the location thing,” she noted on a November 2024 episode of the Almost Famous podcast. “You really can’t know someone in four weeks. I’ll just say that.”

In November 2025, Gerry shared much more, detailing their long list of incompatibilities in his memoir Golden Years. They didn’t agree on everything from food to how to spend money, but the biggest issue, according to Turner, was Theresa going back on her plan to retire because she wanted another year to build her nest egg. 

“I was a little resentful because her economic situation wasn’t at all what she had described on the show,” wrote Gerry, “leaving me to wonder what else I had misunderstood or she had misrepresented.”