Which Bands Formed with All Members Except One from a Previous Group?

The dynamics of band breakups can often be quite intricate. These separations may stem from a singular, specific incident, or they might arise from a buildup of unresolved tension over time. In many cases, the underlying issue is the incompatibility of the group members, which can lead to creative differences and personal conflicts that make collaboration challenging.

Throughout musical history, there have been instances where a single musician found themselves at odds with the others, while the rest of the group wanted to continue their musical journey. Consequently, the remaining members would unite to form a new band, leaving the discordant member behind, eager to explore new avenues in music.

This phenomenon doesn’t necessarily imply blame or fault; rather, it reflects a natural evolution of relationships within a band. Differences in vision, creativity, or personal values can lead to such splits, and often, it’s simply a matter of timing and compatibility.

To illustrate this intriguing scenario, we have curated a comprehensive list of bands that showcase all but one member of a previous group. To clarify the criteria for inclusion in this list, we will provide an example that meets the conditions and one that does not.

One notable example is New Order. Following the tragic death of Ian Curtis by suicide, the surviving members of Joy Division made the decision to move forward under a new band name: New Order. Although the lineup has experienced various changes over the years, the initial formation included all of Joy Division’s members, except for Curtis, marking a significant moment in music history.

DISCOVER MORE: 10 Instances Where All But One Member of a Band Departed Simultaneously

On the contrary, an example that may seem similar but does not fit this criteria is Velvet Revolver. Members Slash, Duff McKagan, and Matt Sorum created Velvet Revolver after their individual departures from Guns N’ Roses, but they chose not to include a rhythm guitarist from their previous band, such as Izzy Stradlin or Gilby Clarke. Instead, they recruited Dave Kushner, who had never been part of GN’R, along with Scott Weiland from Stone Temple Pilots.

Now that the parameters for inclusion are clearly defined, continue reading to uncover which other bands have made our curated list alongside New Order.

Subscribe to Loudwire on YouTube for more exciting content!