When James Gunn made the bold decision to recast Superman for his ambitious DC Studios relaunch, he ignited a firestorm of reactions from the fan community. While Henry Cavill delivered a memorable portrayal of the Man of Steel that garnered acclaim, the movies themselves sparked a range of opinions among audiences. Gunn’s choice to take the DC Universe in a fresh direction left many questioning his vision. Nevertheless, his selection of David Corenswet to take on the iconic role has generally been well-received, with both fans and critics recognizing his talent. This positive reception could pave the way for Corenswet to enjoy a prosperous tenure within the evolving DCU.

The burning question now is: where does Corenswet rank among the legendary portrayals of Superman on the big screen? Our own Tyler Nichols has positioned him as a close second to the all-time favorite, Christopher Reeve. However, we are eager to hear your thoughts on this matter. It’s time to open the floor to you, our dedicated readers, to share your opinions and vote.

To ensure a comprehensive discussion, we have included actors who portrayed Superman on television in our poll. However, we have excluded portrayals of Superboy, such as Tom Welling’s, since they did not depict the fully realized Man of Steel. As a result, performers like George Reeves and Dean Cain are included in the voting options for this exciting comparison.

I am genuinely intrigued to observe how the Superman fandom will cast their votes in this poll. Personally, while I hold both Corenswet and Cavill in high regard for their interpretations of this beloved character, I believe that there will always be one ultimate Superman in my heart, and that is undeniably Christopher Reeve. For those who wish to celebrate his remarkable legacy, I highly recommend watching Super/Man: The Christopher Reeve Story, which is currently available for streaming on HBO Max.