The secret celebrity revealed that this specific family member was quite strict, once grounding her in front of Madonna and Sean Penn for being late to dinner. 

The package also suggested that her family member might be a singer, as it featured a record player alongside his photo. 

“For a time, I resented him for not making my life easier,” Calla Lily reflected on their relationship. “There were years when we were distant.”

Fortunately, they reconciled, with Calla Lily expressing, “I’m grateful for everything he does for me. It taught me to be tough, strong, and always punctual for dinner.”

After her rendition of the 1980s classic, the judges received another hint: a diamond house key, which instantly sparked Jenny’s idea of who it could be. 

“I see a house key and I see a diamond. That sounds like a Beverly Hills Housewife to me,” the judge elaborated. “Combine the clues: gummy bear. Bear. Teddi. Cougar, dad’s nickname. Mellencamp. Cougar. This is Teddi Mellencamp from the Housewives.”

Jenny acknowledged she “could be wrong” but believed all the clues pointed “in that direction.” 

“I just honor your journey, girlfriend,” Jenny stated, “and I feel so privileged to have you here.”