Estimated Reading Duration: 3 minutes

Are the rumors surrounding the feud between Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar genuine and intensifying?

Both of these talented actresses rose to fame in the 1990s, capturing the hearts of audiences worldwide. Now, they are both nurturing families as dedicated moms. Additionally, both starred in the iconic horror film I Know What You Did Last Summer, which has become a classic in the slasher genre.

In an exciting turn, Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. — who is Gellar’s husband — reprised their original characters for the much-anticipated 2025 sequel film. This return has generated significant buzz among fans of the original.

However, the premiere event only served to stoke the flames of speculation regarding a potential feud between the two actresses. Here’s what Gellar has had to say about the situation.

Sarah Michelle Gellar attends the premiere of Columbia Pictures’ I Know What You Did Last Summer at The United Theater on Broadway on July 14, 2025. (Photo Credit: Monica Schipper/Getty Images)

Does the release of the new ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ provide clues about a long-standing feud?

On her Instagram account, Sarah Michelle Gellar shared a collection of photos from the premiere, featuring both familiar and new faces — but notably absent was Jennifer Love Hewitt.

In her enthusiastic caption, she wrote: “What a night!!! I can’t believe it’s been years (no need to age myself) since I walked the red carpet for another premiere of @ikwydlsmovie.”

Additionally, Gellar expressed her admiration for her co-star, stating, “Still starring the most handsome man I know @realfreddieprinze.”

The striking absence of any reference to Hewitt led many commenters to speculate in Gellar’s mentions, suggesting that the rumors of a feud might indeed have some truth to them.

One commenter boldly asserted: “The beef is real.”

Another user lamented: “It makes me so sad there is ZERO recognition for Jennifer Love Hewitt.”

Jennifer Love Hewitt attends the premiere of Columbia Pictures’ I Know What You Did Last Summer at The United Theater on Broadway on July 14, 2025. (Photo Credit: Monica Schipper/Getty Images)

Sarah Michelle Gellar Clarifies the Absence of Jennifer Love Hewitt in the Premiere Photos

In response to the speculation, Sarah Michelle Gellar addressed the situation directly on Instagram, stating, “For everyone asking — I never got to see @jenniferlovehewitt, who is fantastic in the movie.”

She elaborated by saying, “I was inside with my kids during the main carpet event,” explaining her absence during the red carpet interactions. “Unfortunately, JLH didn’t attend the after-party.”

Premiere events can be quite complex, often designed primarily for film publicity. Real-life commitments, children, and personal schedules can complicate interactions between stars.

Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, Sarah Pidgeon, and Gabriette Bechtel attend the premiere of Columbia Pictures’ I Know What You Did Last Summer at The United Theater on Broadway on July 14, 2025. (Photo Credit: Monica Schipper/Getty Images)

Gellar continued her explanation, saying, “If you have been to one of these events, you know how chaotic it can be.”

She noted, “Sadly, I didn’t manage to capture photos with most of the cast.”

Emphasizing her admiration, she stated, “But that doesn’t diminish how incredible I believe they all are.”

Gellar reminded her followers that “unfortunately, some moments happen only in reality and not in the digital world.”

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. attend the premiere of Columbia Pictures’ I Know What You Did Last Summer at The United Theater on Broadway on July 14, 2025. (Photo Credit: Monica Schipper/Getty Images)

Exploring the Legacy of ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ as a Defining Slasher Film

The original I Know What You Did Last Summer film was a pivotal moment in cinematic history, propelling Jennifer Love Hewitt into the spotlight while simultaneously serving as the backdrop for Sarah Michelle Gellar‘s chance meeting with her future husband, Freddie Prinze Jr..

The two actors met while filming and eventually tied the knot in 2002, and they now share two beautiful children together, embodying a strong family unit.

In addition to their successful partnership in Scooby-Doo, they have also made appearances in various Star Wars media, solidifying their status as a beloved and enduring celebrity couple. Their relationship is characterized by its low-drama and grounded nature, which resonates well with fans.