Thirty-two years ago, Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen brewed up Double, Double Toil and Trouble.

By this time, the then 7-year-old twins were already the youngest self-made millionaires. After launching their careers at the young age of 8 months with the shared role of Michelle Tanner on Full House, Mary-Kate and Ashley quickly grew their empire. The child stars turned fashion designers created their own company Dualstar, which would go on to produce all of their straight-to-VHS movies—including, of course, Double, Double Toil and Trouble.

The TV movie premiered on ABC October 30, 1993, and has gone on to become a somewhat overlooked Halloween offering, aside from the Olsen twins’ loyal fanbase who grew up obsessed with the sisters’ songs and movies. But Double, Double Toil and Trouble is filled with lots of ’90s nostalgia, surprising moments, and a cast that also includes Eric McCormack (though he previously admitted he didn’t actually watch the film).

“No, I never have,” the Will & Grace alum, who wasn’t a big fan of his longer hairstyle in the movie, told Entertainment Weekly in 2021. “It’s hard to go back and see…certain looks. And also, I was probably a year-and-a-half into television, so I was still trying to adapt my stage acting to the camera. Maybe I was terrified to go back and watch it.”