ESPN commentator Pat McAfee expressed his frustration towards John Mellencamp after the rock star publicly criticized his mid-game speech during Game 4 of the NBA Finals. McAfee did not hold back, telling Mellencamp to “shut the fuck up.” This incident highlights the intersection of sports and celebrity culture, as McAfee, a former punter for the Indianapolis Colts from 2009 to 2016, has gained significant fame as one of the most entertaining personalities in sports television.

During the NBA Finals game featuring the Indiana Pacers against the New York Knicks, McAfee took to the public address system to rally the crowd. He noted the presence of high-profile Knicks fans, including Spike Lee, Ben Stiller, and Timothée Chalamet, who had traveled to Indianapolis to support their team. McAfee urged the audience to “send these sons of bitches back to New York with their ears ringing,” emphasizing his passion for the game and the rivalry.

Although he did not mention McAfee directly, Mellencamp, a lifelong Indiana resident also attending the game, voiced his disapproval on social media. He expressed embarrassment over the way McAfee called out New York fans, stating that it did not reflect true Hoosier Hospitality. He lamented that the audience booed the visiting fans, which he felt was a poor display of sportsmanship.

Mellencamp further emphasized his disappointment, saying, “On behalf of most Hoosiers, I would like to apologize for our poor behavior.” His comments resonated with many, as he underscored the importance of good sportsmanship and respect for all fans, regardless of their team allegiance. The term “smackdown” he used, perhaps unintentionally, also has a humorous connection to McAfee’s current role as a commentator and occasional wrestler for the WWE.

This online feud prompted McAfee to respond passionately during his ESPN show, where he sarcastically addressed Mellencamp’s critique. He pointed out that Mellencamp has built a career on being outspoken about various issues, but he found the timing and execution of Mellencamp’s tweet to be lacking. “What a moment for John Coug yesterday,” McAfee remarked, questioning the effectiveness of Mellencamp’s social media post.

McAfee continued his address with a blend of humor and criticism, highlighting the flaws in Mellencamp’s tweet and graphic. He noted, “You’re two days late, John! You’re two days late, Bub,” before firmly telling Mellencamp to “shut the fuck up.” This exchange underscores the blending of sports commentary and celebrity interactions, drawing attention from fans and media alike.

Read More: John Mellencamp Demands to See ‘C—sucker Heckler’ After Show

As the Pacers lead the Eastern Conference finals three games to two, the upcoming Game 6 in Indianapolis promises to be electrifying. McAfee’s enthusiasm for the game is palpable, as he suggested the possibility of adding a steel cage match to the evening’s entertainment. His playful rivalry with Mellencamp adds an extra layer of excitement to the event.

McAfee concluded his commentary with a cheeky challenge to Mellencamp, saying, “Hey Coug, suck it buddy! Hope I get a chance to see you real soon.” He made it clear that he does not appreciate Mellencamp’s criticisms and is ready for a face-to-face encounter. However, he did acknowledge one undeniable truth about Mellencamp: “Your songs are pretty good,” highlighting a grudging respect amidst their rivalry.

Watch Pat McAfee Address the Indiana Pacers Crowd

Watch Pat McAfee