Poppy made a striking return to the Jimmy Kimmel Live stage on Monday night, March 10, captivating the audience with her powerful performance of “The Cost of Giving Up,” a standout track from her latest album, Negative Spaces. The song delves into profound themes, resonating with listeners who appreciate her unique blend of heavy sound and emotional depth. Her ability to convey vulnerability while showcasing her vocal prowess is what makes her performances memorable and impactful.

Previously, in late November, Poppy graced the Kimmel stage alongside the band Knocked Loose, where she contributed to the Grammy-nominated track “Suffocate.” The intensity of that performance surprised many viewers, eliciting mixed reactions on social media. This unexpected heaviness delighted metal fans, creating a buzz around her artistic capabilities and genre-defying style.

How did Poppy’s solo performance resonate with the Kimmel audience this time? Did it garner a more positive reception? Discover her riveting rendition of “The Cost of Giving Up” and the audience’s reactions below.

Experience Poppy’s Powerful Performance of “The Cost of Giving Up” on Jimmy Kimmel Live

Audience Reactions to Poppy’s Captivating Performance on Jimmy Kimmel Live

As seen in the performance, Poppy took to the stage dressed in a stunning white dress paired with white boots, complemented by striking red gloves and surrounded by a beautifully arranged floral backdrop. The performance began with an electro-rock vibe, showcasing her mesmerizing clean vocals that drew the audience in with their ethereal quality.

As the song progressed, the atmosphere shifted dramatically; Poppy’s clean vocals transformed into fierce aggressive screams, adding an exhilarating layer to the performance. At pivotal moments, she knelt down or gazed skyward, channeling raw emotion through her powerful screams, culminating in an explosive full-vocal scream that left the audience in awe.

The comments section on the Kimmel YouTube video buzzed with various reactions. A recurring theme involved callbacks to the earlier performance with Knocked Loose, where fans humorously mocked those who might not appreciate Poppy’s heavier sound. One fan quipped, “I’d pay money to see the reactions of the crowd during this one,” while another joked, “This music made my kid cry – Jimmy – AGAIN!” Another chimed in, “By the third ‘Junt,’ my adolescent son was in tears.” A third witty comment noted, “People who were mad last time about the song with Knocked Loose probably thought they were getting a nice sweet song this time, but she pulled a little sneaky on ’em.”

Another popular commentary thread referenced the viral moment at the Grammys when Spiritbox’s Courtney LaPlante was mistaken for Poppy during a red carpet interview. Fans expressed their joy at seeing LaPlante as well, with comments like, “It’s always good to see Courtney LaPlante singing solo sometimes,” and “OMG!!! Spiritbox!!!!” Another fan added, “I’m so glad that Courtney is finally on Jimmy Kimmel!”

Overall, the feedback regarding Poppy’s performance was overwhelmingly positive across both YouTube and X comments. One fan enthusiastically stated, “Her screams sound so good here,” while another noted, “Poppy is improving her performance skills every day & I am floored by her screaming every time.” A fan on X social media exclaimed, “Poppy ATE and left no crumbs with her Kimmel performance. That was easily her best live performance to date!”

Many comments acknowledged the significance of this mainstream appearance for Poppy. One fan passionately proclaimed, “Thanks Poppy for keeping metal alive and being on a live TV show,” while another shared, “So glad to see Poppy doing more promo performances this era, she deserves the attention.” A third remarked, “So good to see her finally in her mainstream era; she’s worked so hard for this!”

One fan beautifully summarized the impact of her performance, saying, “What an absolute magnetic performance. Her future self is going to thank her for not giving up. And so will we. Pure hearts always win in the end.” Another fan appreciated Jimmy Kimmel’s support for artists like Poppy, stating, “I love that after some people criticized Jimmy for having Knocked Loose and Poppy perform live, he doubles down and invites Poppy back.” A different fan added, “I absolutely love Jimmy Kimmel for showcasing artists like Poppy.” Another praised the increasing representation of metal bands on mainstream platforms, saying, “It’s been so incredible seeing proper metal bands making it onto mainstream shows like Kimmel.” One final fan remarked, “The most underappreciated genre in music, nice to see metal finally being represented on mainstream television,” while another shared, “I fkn love this. Importantly, I love the Jimmy Kimmel show for doubling down on Poppy and having her scream her heart out again!”

Catch Poppy Live on Her Upcoming Tour in 2025

While Poppy’s performance on Jimmy Kimmel Live was a powerful showcase of her talent, fans can look forward to experiencing her full-fledged stage show as she embarks on her current tour titled “They’re All Around Us.” Her next stop is in San Francisco on March 11, followed by shows in Portland, Seattle, Salt Lake City, and Denver in the coming week. This tour promises to deliver an unforgettable experience filled with her unique sound and captivating stage presence.

For all current Poppy tour dates and ticketing information, be sure to visit her official website. Fans can also explore her latest album, Negative Spaces, and shop for exclusive merchandise to support her artistic journey.