Many television series would consider themselves fortunate to have a pilot episode that matches even a fraction of the brilliance exhibited in the premiere of <em>The Sopranos</em>. This groundbreaking debut episode, aptly named after its titular series, opened the doors for HBO viewers to experience a unique family dynamic that was largely uncharted for audiences accustomed to traditional network television. The character of Tony Soprano, played masterfully by James Gandolfini, is depicted as a devoted and caring family man, yet he also embodies the persona of an influential and formidable mob boss. Adding complexity to his character, Tony grapples with debilitating panic attacks, which compel him to seek help from a psychiatrist. The innovative concept is not only presented with clarity but also executed with vigor, showcasing the creative prowess of its creator, David Chase. However, Chase has harbored a long-standing concern about one particular music selection that, in his view, undermines the show’s exploration of violence and the darkness that ultimately permeates the series.

The Early Episodes of ‘The Sopranos’ Featured a Lighter Tone

By the time Season 7 arrived, The Sopranos delved into increasingly darker themes, a direction that David Chase embraced wholeheartedly. The writers took a bold step to challenge the audience’s sympathies by stripping their characters of any redeeming qualities, presenting a stark examination of their deteriorating moral fabric. Characters like Tony, Silvio (Stevie Van Zandt), Paulie (Tony Sirico), and Christopher (Michael Imperioli) were shown not only as morally reprehensible individuals but also as products of a bleak American landscape characterized by the corrupting influence of capitalism and a pervasive sense of uncertainty. This transformation marked a significant departure from the lighter tones established in earlier episodes.

In fact, Season 1, especially the four episodes leading up to the pivotal “College,” often regarded as a turning point and a benchmark for subsequent prestige television, carries a surprisingly light and comedic tone when viewed through a modern lens. While the entire series is renowned for its humor, Season 1, which premiered in 1999, almost feels like an edgy sitcom, and at times, it serves as a sharp satire of mob narratives. The title itself, which could easily be mistaken for a commentary on vocal ranges or the plethora of mob-themed comedies, belies the show’s true potential to redefine the boundaries of television storytelling. Adding to the complexity, just two months post-premiere, Analyze This, featuring Robert De Niro and Billy Crystal, hit theaters, presenting a comedic take on a mobster grappling with emotional turmoil.

Viewers initially perceived The Sopranos as a comedic farce centered on a tough gangster who undergoes an existential crisis after his ducks mysteriously fly away from his pool. Those revisiting the series will undoubtedly be taken aback by the significant evolution of The Sopranos since its inception. Observations such as the change in actors portraying Father Phil Intintola, along with Tony’s lack of a stereotypical Italian-American New Jersey accent, highlight the show’s growth. The narrative unfolds from Tony’s perspective, serving as a reflective narration of the events leading up to his anxiety-driven panic attack, which leads him to seek assistance from Dr. Jennifer Melfi (Lorraine Bracco).

David Chase Reflects on a Regrettable Song Choice in ‘The Sopranos’ Pilot

Even the most ardent fans of The Sopranos might find themselves questioning, “Was this show originally intended to be a comedy?” after witnessing the scene where Tony and Christopher pursue a colleague deep in debt, culminating in Tony running him over with Christopher’s car and beating him while he lies injured. The comical chase across the office building’s lawn is set to the tune of “I Wonder Why,” a doo-wop classic from 1959 by Dion and the Belmonts. The Sopranos, bolstered by the casting of Lorraine Bracco, Michael Imperioli, and numerous other supporting actors, never shied away from its clear Goodfellas influences. The shadow of Martin Scorsese loomed large over this scene, where a light-hearted song is juxtaposed against the brutal violence, a stylistic choice popularized by Scorsese in the 1970s with his film Mean Streets.

In the DVD commentary for the pilot episode, David Chase candidly expressed his regret regarding this particular music selection. Speaking alongside filmmaker and recurring cast member Peter Bogdanovich, he described the needle drop as “hackneyed” and “silly,” even going so far as to apologize to audiences for presenting a series that would ultimately span 86 episodes of gripping entertainment. Bogdanovich attempted to reassure him, suggesting that the doo-wop track successfully created a “sarcastic tone,” highlighting the stark contrast between the visuals and the accompanying audio.

Regrettably, I must concur with Chase’s assessment. The use of “I Wonder Why” significantly underscores the tonal inconsistencies present in the show’s initial episodes. While the series would later embrace the notion of deriving humor from dark situations, their expertly crafted black comedy was never this overt and broad. Overlaying a nostalgic ’50s doo-wop melody over a violent mob hit could have seamlessly fit into a film like Married to the Mob or even its 1999 counterpart, Analyze This, making it feel increasingly jarring when compared to the show’s later seasons. The Sopranos gained acclaim for its audacious use of obscure pop music that enriched the subtle thematic and character developments woven into the narrative, but this moment leans too heavily into a generalized notion of “isn’t the mob outrageous?” mentality.

The Evolution of ‘The Sopranos’ From Season 1’s Broad Humor to Darker Themes

Peter Bogdanovich’s remark regarding the sarcasm of this particular scene is intriguing, as The Sopranos consistently avoided resorting to overtly tongue-in-cheek portrayals of mafia life throughout its impressive seven-season run. Although numerous internet memes have emerged from the show, it remained authentic and never sacrificed its humorous undertone. The use of “I Wonder Why” encapsulates what a more conventional, less inquisitive interpretation of The Sopranos might resemble: a modern mob saga filled with glib humor about characters who are desperately clinging to their past glories. Subversion was central to Chase’s vision, as he dismantled the long-standing myths of nobility and “coolness” associated with criminal figures glorified over the past century.

Until the pivotal episode “College,” which serves as a crucial lens through which to understand The Sopranos‘ synthesis of family dynamics and criminal undertakings, the acclaimed HBO drama carried a distinct energy akin to a single-camera sitcom, characterized by bold performances and a sardonic atmosphere. The moment Tony executes a former mafioso-turned-family man in broad daylight, comparisons to Analyze This ceased. In Season 2, as Tony seeks new therapy after Dr. Melfi temporarily ceases their sessions, a counselor turns him away upon discovering he watched Analyze This, prompting Tony’s sarcastic retort, “It’s a f–king comedy!” This marked the rapid evolution of the show into an unflinching examination of humanity’s decline and the angst of the 21st century, a transformation that audiences came to cherish, earning the writers their well-deserved accolades.

Even for a visionary like David Chase, finding the right tonal and narrative balance in a television series often takes time. The journey was not without its missteps, including an ill-conceived music selection that continues to irk Chase to this day, yet The Sopranos ultimately established itself as the quintessential prestige cable drama that reshaped the television landscape for generations to come.

[nospin]Here you can find the original article; the photos and images used in our article also come from this source. We are not their authors; they have been used solely for informational purposes with proper attribution to their original source.[/nospin]

Share on Facebook

Post on X

Follow us

Save