The latest Grammy Awards have concluded, and as is tradition, we reflect on whether the Grammys made the right choice for the coveted Best Rock Album category. Over the years, the Academy has had moments of brilliance, delivering well-deserved recognition, but there have also been instances that left fans scratching their heads in disbelief.

Metal enthusiasts frequently express their dissatisfaction with the nominees in the Best Metal Performance category, yet the Best Rock Album Grammy has also sparked its fair share of controversy. In this comprehensive recap, we will delve into the winners from the inception of the Best Rock Album Grammy in 1995 to the most recent victor, analyzing each year’s outcome to determine how accurately the Academy represented the rock genre.

There are standout years when the Recording Academy excelled not only in selecting the rightful winners but also in curating a compelling list of nominees. While you might anticipate some exciting revelations, we will also spotlight years where the choice of winner was puzzling, prompting discussions about the criteria used for selection.

While award shows often emphasize that “it’s just an honor to be nominated,” we will showcase remarkable rock albums that were shockingly overlooked for nominations in their respective years, leaving fans and critics alike wondering, “How did that happen?”

READ MORE: Every Rock Band That Lost the Best New Artist Grammy + One Who Actually Won

Join us as we navigate through the gallery below, taking a detailed look at each year to reveal who won and who truly deserved the Best Rock Album Grammy.