Insights from ‘Superman’ OG Dean Cain
James Gunn’s Comments Spark Controversy Over Immigration Themes…
But I’m Still Excited to Watch It!

Published on July 9, 2025, at 1:00 AM PDT

The upcoming film “Superman” has stirred up significant controversy even before its release, particularly among conservative media outlets, which are criticizing its potential pro-immigration narrative. This backlash stems from remarks made by director James Gunn, who indicated that the film explores themes of immigration and human kindness—concepts he believes are essential yet overlooked in contemporary society. Dean Cain, the actor famous for his portrayal of Superman in “Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman,” suggests these political undertones could negatively impact box office performance.

The specific comments from James Gunn to The Sunday Times included references to the film’s focus on an “immigrant” and the importance of “basic human kindness.” These statements have been interpreted by some conservatives as indicative of a so-called “woke” agenda, especially in the context of the Trump administration’s stringent immigration policies and ongoing ICE raids. The director’s statements have ignited further debate about the film’s messaging and its appeal to a broader audience in a politically charged environment.

Dean Cain, who donned the iconic red cape in the beloved series, expressed initial enthusiasm for the new film but felt disheartened by Gunn’s political rhetoric, which he believes could alienate fans. Cain’s concerns reflect a sentiment shared by some in the fandom who fear that the film’s creative direction may prioritize political commentary over entertainment. Fans are left pondering whether these themes will resonate positively or hinder the film’s reception among diverse audiences.

The actor, known for his conservative viewpoints and occasional political commentary, speculated that the controversy surrounding the immigrant theme could indeed affect the film’s box office success. However, he remains hopeful that “Superman” will ultimately be a triumph. The discourse surrounding the film has been amplified by personalities from Fox News, with figures like Kellyanne Conway asserting that audiences do not attend theaters to receive lectures, while Jesse Watters jokingly suggested that “MS-13” might as well be emblazoned on Superman’s cape, illustrating the intense scrutiny the film is facing.

Many fans, including Dean, find it frustrating that Gunn’s remarks were even necessary, given the well-established understanding that Superman is an immigrant—a literal alien from another planet. It is important to note that Superman’s creation in 1938 was influenced by the geopolitical climate of the time, particularly as World War II loomed. The values of “Truth, Justice, and the American Way” are foundational to the character and remain relevant today, serving as a moral compass that transcends current political divides.

Dean acknowledges that opinions are varied, especially as the political climate has intensified in recent years. He emphasizes that not every artistic endeavor needs to convey a profound message; sometimes, art can simply be enjoyable. His hope is that “Superman” will deliver a thrilling and entertaining experience for audiences, preserving the essence of what makes the superhero genre beloved by many.

Explore Additional Insights and Related Articles