Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for The Stolen Girl episode 4

For the first time since the premiere of The Stolen Girl, I find myself genuinely eager to see what unfolds next. Episode 4 takes place seven weeks after the abduction of Lucia (portrayed by Beatrice Campbell) and intricately ties together multiple storylines, leading to a surprise twist that will leave viewers stunned. The previous episode effectively illustrates Rebecca’s (played by Holliday Grainger, known for her role in Cinderella) motives behind the kidnapping of a child. However, it raises a critical question that lingers in the air: Why specifically target Lucia? Initially, I suspected her choice of Elisa‘s (played by Denise Gough, recognized from Andor) daughter might have been random, yet Episode 4 unveils deeper layers to this narrative.

As we approach the finale airing next week, I’ve come to realize how much I’ll miss these characters and the profound complexities their internal struggles contribute to the storyline. As someone who enjoys weekly television series with extensive 20-episode seasons, I was surprised by how quickly I grew attached to them in such a brief time. Episode 4 kept me completely captivated for the entire hour, prompting me to reflect on its events long after the credits rolled. Despite my growing interest in this miniseries and the rich experiences it offers, I find it hard to imagine my engagement with this psychological drama extending beyond the five episodes it has been allotted.

The Intriguing Connection Between Rebecca and the Inmate Unfolds

Marcus Turner: The Inmate Convicted of Manslaughter

In Episode 4, Selma (played by Ambika Mod, known for her role in Netflix’s One Day) continues to demonstrate her prowess in investigative journalism, making a significant discovery that both Elisa and the authorities have overlooked. She delves into the details surrounding Marcus Turner‘s manslaughter trial and requests previously unreleased images from the press conference. In these photos, Selma identifies Rebecca, whose true identity is revealed as Nina Thibault. The accompanying caption identifies her as the wife of Nicolas Thibault and mother of Rose Thibault, both of whom tragically lost their lives.

Following her conversation with Selma, Elisa decides to visit Marcus in prison, seeking to uncover if anyone else is aware of the truth regarding the incident that led to the accident. Elisa’s palpable concern implies her potential involvement, suggesting she might have been the one behind the wheel. Marcus reveals that Nina has paid him a visit in prison, but he holds back the secret that Elisa is desperately trying to keep hidden. The episode takes a surprising twist when it is disclosed that George is, in fact, Marcus’ biological son, not Fred’s.

Nevertheless, numerous questions persist. How did Rebecca come to know the truth about the events of that day? Additionally, is Fred aware that George is not his biological son? Elisa insists that she and Marcus were not involved in an affair, which makes her relationship with Fred even more perplexing. With so many loose ends to tie up before the final episode, I am concerned that The Stolen Girl may not have sufficient time to address each plotline appropriately.

Anticipating the Exciting Team-Up in The Stolen Girl Finale

Elisa and Selma Join Forces to Track Down Rebecca

From the outset, I had anticipated that the dynamic between Elisa and Selma would take center stage in this miniseries. While that hasn’t been entirely realized, Episode 4 lays the groundwork for an empowering team-up between these two women as The Stolen Girl approaches its conclusion. Elisa implores Selma not to report her findings to the police, fearing it would lead to her arrest just as she is closing in on a lead regarding Lucia in Toulon. Selma, as a seasoned journalist, puts forward her conditions, including the withdrawal of the complaint regarding her recent article. However, there was one particular condition I was anxiously waiting to hear.

The words, “I’m coming with you,” were precisely what I had hoped to hear, and I am eager to witness the journey that these reluctant allies embark upon. Elisa is now prepared to share everything with Selma, which will undoubtedly provide the audience with long-awaited clarity and answers. It is no secret that I have harbored doubts regarding the predictability of the series, and I still maintain that it may not leave a significant impact on viewers. Nevertheless, Episode 4 stands out as the most compelling installment of The Stolen Girl, as the revelations elevate the psychological drama in unexpected and thrilling ways.

The Stolen Girl is available for streaming on Disney+ globally, with new episodes premiering every Wednesday at 10 p.m. ET on Freeform.