In an engaging conversation, the two esteemed actors share their insights on the complex challenges presented by their roles, while John Lithgow reflects on a selection of his most iconic villainous characters throughout his illustrious career.

It’s always thrilling to witness renowned actors venture into the realm of horror films. Both John Lithgow and Geoffrey Rush have consistently embraced this genre, seeking out compelling roles that challenge their extraordinary talents. Their latest collaboration in The Rule of Jenny Pen serves as a perfect example, providing a rich landscape for these two performers to explore. Their dynamic as adversaries creates an electric atmosphere, with palpable tension evident in every shared scene. The way they capitalize on subtle interactions heightens the emotional stakes, drawing the audience into their complex relationship. Although my personal take on the film may not be overwhelmingly positive (for my thoughts, check out my review HERE), I was undeniably impressed by the remarkable performances delivered by these two accomplished actors.

Engaging in a dialogue with acting legends like John Lithgow and Geoffrey Rush can feel somewhat daunting. However, their warm personalities and genuine passion for the craft make for a comfortable and enjoyable conversation. Their camaraderie is evident, particularly when Rush inquires about Lithgow’s experience with a specific Shakespearean play. I found myself wishing for more time to delve deeper into their thoughts, as their responses were insightful and thought-provoking. Lithgow’s extensive history of portraying iconic villains led me to ask him which character—The Trinity Killer from Dexter, Carter/Cain from Raising Cain, or Dave Crealy—exhibits the most humanity. His answer may take you by surprise, so be sure to catch all the details in the embedded video above!

The Rule of Jenny Pen offers a gripping narrative:

Judge Stefan Mortensen, played by Geoffrey Rush, is an arrogant figure who suffers a life-altering stroke, leaving him partially paralyzed and confined within a retirement home. Initially resistant to the staff and emotionally distant from his friendly roommate, Mortensen soon finds himself at odds with the seemingly gentle resident, Dave Crealy, portrayed by John Lithgow. However, Crealy harbors a dark secret, inflicting terror upon the home through a sadistic game he calls “The Rule of Jenny Pen,” using his dementia doll as a tool for cruelty. What begins as innocent torment quickly spirals into a series of increasingly sinister and disturbing events. When Mortensen’s desperate cries for help go unheard by the staff, he resolves to confront Crealy and put an end to his reign of terror.

THE RULE OF JENNY PEN HITS THEATERS ON MARCH 7TH AND WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR STREAMING ON SHUDDER STARTING MARCH 20TH, 2025.

Meet Tyler Nichols: Your Go-To Horror Expert

Tyler Nichols is a dedicated horror enthusiast based in Michigan, perpetually on the lookout for the next captivating film. When he’s not scouring the internet for the latest movie news, he enjoys immersing himself in dark cinematic experiences, sharing his unique observations through writing, or exploring fantastical realms in video games. While horror occupies a significant portion of his time, he also appreciates films across various genres, particularly those that are strange and unconventional. Additionally, he possesses extensive knowledge of all things related to Comic Book Cinema. Alongside his reviews and interviews featured on JoBlo.com, Tyler contributes to JoBlo Horror Originals, where he passionately advocates for lesser-known horror films, encouraging viewers to discover hidden gems within the genre.