In the ongoing debate about which Metallica album reigns supreme, the question arises: is Load more iconic than Reload? This week on Chuck’s Fight Club, part of the Loudwire Nights radio show, we delve into this contentious topic, and we invite you to weigh in with your opinions and preferences.

The 1980s marked a pivotal decade for thrash metal, showcasing some of the most remarkable works from Metallica’s extensive catalog. Although the band’s self-titled Black Album, released in 1991, initially faced skepticism, the Metallica fanbase has largely embraced it over time. However, the consecutive releases of Load and Reload in the mid-90s have sparked numerous discussions regarding the artistic quality and evolution of the band’s music.

First, let’s explore Load. Despite facing criticism from some quarters, the album enjoyed impressive commercial success, driven by hit singles like “Until It Sleeps,” “Hero of the Day,” “Mama Said,” and “King Nothing.” Load not only topped the Billboard 200 Album Chart but also achieved a remarkable milestone by being certified five times platinum in the United States, solidifying its place in rock history.

Following closely in 1997 was Reload, which was originally intended to be part of a double album alongside Load. However, Reload stands strong as a standalone work. The album featured popular singles such as “The Memory Remains,” “Unforgiven II,” “Fuel,” and “Better Than You,” each contributing to the album’s success. Like its predecessor, Reload debuted at No. 1 on the charts and has been certified four times platinum, showcasing its widespread appeal and enduring legacy.

READ MORE: Kirk Hammett Reveals Which Metallica Album Showcases His Best Guitar Work

As with all battles in Chuck’s Fight Club, host Chuck Armstrong will introduce this intriguing matchup during the 8 PM hour of Monday’s Loudwire Nights. Each album will be passionately defended in dedicated discussions on Tuesday and Wednesday at 8 PM, while you can actively participate by ranking your preferences using the interactive tool located at the bottom of this post. The final rankings will be revealed on Friday afternoon, and the winning album will be celebrated with a special Loudwire Nights rock block during the 8 PM hour of Friday’s show.

Don’t forget, Loudwire Nights with Chuck Armstrong airs every evening starting at 7 PM ET. You can tune in from anywhere at any time by clicking right here or by downloading the Loudwire app for easy access.