The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has unveiled an exciting list of 14 acts that are in the running for potential induction into the 2025 class. Here at Loudwire, we are eager to share our insights and opinions on this diverse lineup of nominees. Each artist represents a unique facet of the music landscape, showcasing the rich tapestry of sounds that have emerged from the rock era spanning from 1955 to the present day.

The nominees for 2025 include iconic names such as Bad Company, The Black Crowes, Mariah Carey, Chubby Checker, Joe Cocker, Billy Idol, Cyndi Lauper, Mana, Joy Division/New Order, Oasis, Outkast, Phish, Soundgarden, and The White Stripes. This eclectic mix highlights the breadth of talent that has defined rock music throughout the decades, and it?s a testament to the genre’s enduring influence.

Since the first induction class in 1986, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has made significant strides in recognizing artists from earlier decades, leading to the inclusion of performers who peaked during the ’60s, ’70s, and ’80s. Many of these artists have only recently received their first nominations despite being eligible for years, reflecting the ongoing evolution of the Hall’s selection process.

Every year, fans express disappointment when their favorite artists are overlooked, while others celebrate the acknowledgment of their idols with hopes of eventual induction. This year?s nominees stir up anticipation and excitement among music enthusiasts, each hoping that their favorites will finally take their rightful place among the legends of rock and roll.

In a roundtable discussion, the staff at Loudwire tackled some burning questions regarding the 2025 nominees. We invite you to explore our perspectives and share your thoughts on the nominations as well.

Exciting First-Time Nominees: Which Artist Stands Out the Most?

Joe DiVita: While I truly admire Chubby Checker?s timeless classic ?The Twist,? it was the nomination of Billy Idol that left me pleasantly surprised. Despite nearly a decade of covering Grammy announcements, I never considered that the Hall had overlooked his contributions until now. His rebellious punk rock spirit, combined with the new wave elements of his era, propelled Billy Idol to superstardom. Idol is an emblematic figure in rock history, and his name resonates with anyone who thinks of true rock stars.

Billy Idol, “Rebel Yell”

Chad Childers: Bad Company has long held a special place in my heart as one of the standout bands from the ?70s. Their music has often been underrated, making their first nomination for the Rock Hall quite surprising. The band’s catalogue is filled with hits, and they even enjoyed a significant resurgence in the ?90s with Brian Howe at the helm. This nomination would be a well-deserved recognition for frontman Paul Rodgers, whose incredible voice has graced multiple legendary bands including Free, Bad Company, The Firm, and Queen. His versatility and range are unmatched, and it?s high time he receives the honor he deserves.

Bad Company, “Rock ‘n’ Roll Fantasy”

Lauryn Schaffner: The Black Crowes hold a special place in my musical journey, as their albums were often on repeat during my childhood road trips with my parents. Their unique blend of blues and rock sets them apart from their contemporaries who leaned more towards grunge and alternative styles in the early ’90s. Despite the prevailing trends, the Crowes remained steadfast to their roots, and their latest album, Happiness Bastards, resonates with the same authenticity as their earlier work. Their commitment to their distinctive sound over the years is truly commendable, showcasing their dedication to their craft.

The Black Crowes, “She Talks to Angels”

Determining the Best Candidate for Immediate Induction: Who Should It Be?

Lauryn Schaffner: Soundgarden is a pivotal band in the history of grunge music, being the first of the ?Big 4? to release a significant track, ?Hunted Down,? back in 1987. Their influence on the genre is immense, comparable to bands like Melvins and Mudhoney, who are often credited with pioneering the grunge sound. However, Nirvana frequently gets the spotlight. With Nirvana already inducted, it?s Soundgarden’s turn to receive the recognition they richly deserve. Chris Cornell was an exceptional vocalist, and his lyrical prowess and musicality are unmatched. The unique contributions of each member, including Kim Thayil’s signature guitar tone and Matt Cameron?s drumming prowess, solidify Soundgarden’s place as a cornerstone of rock history.

Joe DiVita: There?s no debate here: Soundgarden should be the top choice. What I find captivating about the grunge movement is the distinctiveness of its leading bands. Among the grunge ‘Big 4’?Nirvana, Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and Soundgarden?Soundgarden?s diversity and richness in their music stand out. Chris Cornell’s extraordinary vocal range and ability to convey emotion in both the gentle and more aggressive moments are qualities that set him apart as a singer. Their entire ensemble, including the likes of Hiro Yamamoto and Ben Shepherd, contributed significantly to their legacy, making them a deserving candidate for induction.

Soundgarden, “Fell On Black Days”

Chad Childers: I wholeheartedly agree with Lauryn and Joe; Soundgarden undoubtedly boasts the strongest case for induction. While Nirvana and Pearl Jam often dominate discussions about grunge, Soundgarden was a trailblazer in the genre. Their influence on many bands that are already inducted is noteworthy. If this year leads to the release of Cornell’s final works with his bandmates, a Rock Hall induction would serve as the perfect tribute to a remarkable year for the band.

Additionally, I would be thrilled to see Bad Company, Oasis, and Billy Idol receive their due recognition as well.

Identifying the Most Notable Snub: Which Band Should Have Been Nominated?

Joe DiVita: While Iron Maiden is my personal favorite choice, it might be too easy to mention them here. Given Bruce Dickinson?s history of critiquing the Hall, it?s unlikely they would perform if inducted. Instead, I?d like to highlight Motorhead! Though the original members have sadly passed, the legacy of Phil Campbell and Mikkey Dee should also be acknowledged for their contributions to the band. The music community is well aware of their significance and impact.

Chad Childers: Joe accurately captures the essence of Iron Maiden?s snub, so I want to turn the spotlight on a band that deserves more attention?Pixies. This influential band had a remarkable run in the late ’80s, dominating college rock radio with their distinctive sound characterized by Kim Deal’s captivating bass lines and Black Francis’s raw vocals. The Rock Hall considers the cultural impact and influence of artists on future musicians, and Pixies unquestionably laid the groundwork for many grunge bands that followed in the ’90s. Their stylistic innovations can be traced through Nirvana to Weezer, making their omission from the nominations a missed opportunity.

There are numerous bands that could have been nominated this year based on their influence and cultural relevance, and I could easily advocate for Korn and Pantera as well.

READ MORE: Fans React to 2025 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Snubs

Lauryn Schaffner: While my heart leans toward Alice in Chains as one of my all-time favorites, especially among Loudwire’s audience, I?ll pick Pantera this time. This band revolutionized heavy music in the ’90s, allowing metal to thrive alongside the grunge and alternative movements. Their lasting impact is evident, especially with their 2022 comeback, which generated significant buzz. Many fans, including myself, were drawn to Metallica?s tour primarily to see Pantera perform.

Highlighting Newly Eligible Bands: Which Artist Deserves Induction First?

Chad Childers: This is a no-brainer; Linkin Park should be the first band inducted from the newly eligible list. They brought a fresh perspective to the nu-metal scene, connecting with fans on a personal level through their songwriting. This ability to bridge genre gaps has enabled them to become one of the biggest-selling bands of the 21st century, and their influence is undeniable.

While Disturbed may also be considered from the newly eligible bands in the future, Linkin Park stands out as the first band from the 2000s that deserves this recognition.

Joe DiVita: Linkin Park is undoubtedly the right choice! Fans have long recognized their deserving nature for this honor, and it?s disappointing to see them snubbed in their first year of eligibility. If they hadn?t reunited last year, released an impressive comeback album, and headlined major festivals, perhaps one could understand the delay. However, with their remarkable resurgence and new vocalist, it would be a mistake for the Rock Hall to overlook them.

Given the Hall’s willingness to induct rap and hip-hop artists, it would be fitting to acknowledge a band that has successfully merged genres.

Lauryn Schaffner: Although I prefer to provide a unique answer, Linkin Park is the clear front-runner among newly eligible bands. Their influence on the younger generation of musicians is profound, and their triumphant return last year would make a 2025 induction even more momentous.

Let?s hope for better luck next year!

Linkin Park, “In the End”

Choosing a Non-Rock Nominee: Which Act Would You Support?

Joe DiVita: Mariah Carey deserves my vote. Her ability to hit whistle tones is remarkable, and her Christmas songs have become ubiquitous. The power to evoke such strong reactions from the public through your music is undeniably rock ?n? roll.

Chad Childers: I?m voting for the combined nomination of Joy Division/New Order. While Mariah Carey and Outkast have made significant contributions to music, Joy Division and New Order were pioneers of the ?Madchester? scene, introducing fresh sounds that shaped ’80s synth-based rock. Their continuous evolution and influence in the music industry make them iconic figures in this genre.

Lauryn Schaffner: I?m thrilled to express a different opinion! Cyndi Lauper is my top choice without a doubt. She?s a true icon, consistently showcasing her unique style and aesthetic. Even for those who may not be fans of her music, her influence and presence in the industry are undeniable. A true rock star in every sense.

We?ve shared our thoughts, and now it?s time for the Rock Hall voters to cast their ballots. The 2025 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction class will be revealed in late April, with the induction ceremony set to take place in Los Angeles this fall on a date yet to be determined.