Alanis Morissette, a prominent figure in the 1990s music scene, nearly transformed her career with a significant role in a film that has since garnered a cult following. She was considered for the lead in the cult classic Dogma, directed by Kevin Smith, which is currently celebrating its 25th anniversary with screenings across the nation. During a special Q&A segment included in the bonus footage, Smith discusses the film’s enduring legacy and reveals that Morissette, who makes a memorable cameo as God, was initially approached to portray the lead character, Bethany Sloane, a role that ultimately went to Linda Fiorentino.

As fans of the film gather, they reminisce about its impact, and Smith’s insights provide a fascinating glimpse into the casting decisions that shaped this iconic film.

Exploring Alanis Morissette’s Early Acting Journey

Before rising to fame as a musical icon, Morissette showcased her talent in acting during her childhood, appearing in several episodes of the sketch comedy show You Can’t Do That on Television in the late 1980s. This early exposure to performance arts laid the groundwork for her later success in the music industry, which began to flourish shortly thereafter. While her primary focus shifted to her burgeoning career as a singer-songwriter, her acting background enriched her artistic expression, especially in her visually captivating music videos. By the time the opportunity for Dogma arose, Morissette had already established a notable portfolio with over 15 music video credits, demonstrating her versatility and talent.

READ MORE: 15 Best Rock + Metal Movies of the 1990s

Understanding Alanis Morissette’s Initial Refusal of the Role in Dogma

Morissette’s decision to decline the lead role in Dogma was influenced by various factors, including her thriving music career and scheduling conflicts. In a revealing Reddit AMA, Smith shared details about Morissette’s initial reluctance to accept the role. He recalls how she expressed uncertainty about taking on a leading part in a film, citing her lack of experience in acting beyond music videos. Smith, however, recognized her potential and reminded her of her prior performances, which included her comedic timing on You Can’t Do That on Television.

Reflecting on their conversation, Smith noted, “I asked Alanis to play Bethany back in 1996, but she said she couldn’t handle the lead in a movie. She insisted, ‘I’m not an actor,'” to which he countered, “You perform in your music videos.” After some time, when the film was gearing up for production, Smith had already cast Linda Fiorentino as Bethany. While driving to Pittsburgh for rehearsals, he received an unexpected call from Morissette, revealing her change of heart.

During their conversation, she shared her recent spiritual journey in India and her desire to overcome her fears regarding acting. “I remembered that you asked me to play the lead in your movie and I said no. But I did that out of fear, and nothing good comes from not facing a fear,” she explained. This pivotal moment led Smith to consider her for the role of God instead, which perfectly aligned with her unique charm and presence.

Alanis Morissette’s Memorable Role in Dogma and Beyond

In Dogma, Morissette’s portrayal of God is both surprising and memorable, despite the character’s minimal dialogue. Her unexpected entrance adds a humorous twist to the film, showcasing her ability to make a significant impact with a brief appearance. This role marked the beginning of a new chapter in her acting career, opening doors for more television and film projects. Following Dogma, Morissette took on various roles, including notable guest appearances in acclaimed series such as Nip/Tuck and Weeds, as well as in popular shows like Sex and the City and Curb Your Enthusiasm.

Additionally, she lent her voice to the animated series The Great North in a recurring role, further diversifying her portfolio. In 2001, she returned to collaborate with Smith in another film, Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back, further solidifying her connection to the director’s work and the film industry. Although her music career took a backseat after the release of Havoc and Bright Lights in 2012, focusing on family life, Morissette made a triumphant return to music in 2020 with Such Pretty Forks in the Road, and followed up with the release of The Storm Before the Calm in 2022, showcasing her enduring talent and passion for her craft.