To begin with, it’s essential to acknowledge that Buffy the Vampire Slayer was not without its flaws. Similar to many long-running television series that boasted over 20 episodes each season, it faced challenges in maintaining consistent quality. While the overall standard of the show was commendable, the sheer volume of episodes sometimes led to a few that fell short of expectations, resulting in moments of less-than-stellar television. However, these episodes were few and far between, as the majority of the series delivered compelling and engaging content. When Buffy the Vampire Slayer hit its stride, it produced some of the most satisfying and emotionally impactful moments in television history. Among its standout episodes, the following are considered the absolute finest.
10
“The Wish”
Season 3, Episode 9 (1998)
This ranking naturally leans toward episodes that advance the plot or deliver particularly intense drama. However, it also includes several standout “one-off” episodes that deserve recognition as some of the best content ever produced by Buffy the Vampire Slayer. One such example is Season 3’s “The Wish,” which stands out as a hallmark of the show’s most coherent and consistent season. This episode explores the consequences of wish fulfillment in a narrative reminiscent of It’s a Wonderful Life, where Cordelia Chase, feeling despondent, wishes to see a reality devoid of Buffy Summers in Sunnydale. This wish is granted by Anya, making her first appearance in the series. The episode unfolds within a nightmarish alternate universe, showcasing distressing scenarios for beloved characters, though ultimately, normalcy is restored. The juxtaposition of comedic elements against the dark backdrop of tragedy makes this episode a classic. Buffy the Vampire Slayer is well-known for its ability to blend humor with horror.
9
“Chosen”
Season 7, Episode 22 (2003)
In stark contrast to “The Wish,” the series finale titled “Chosen” is undoubtedly one of the most dramatic and consequential episodes in the history of <em>Buffy the Vampire Slayer</em>. Throughout the series, the show has not shied away from the harsh realities of character deaths, but the final confrontation in this episode raises the stakes even higher. In a heart-wrenching moment, Anya meets a tragic fate, and Spike makes a profound sacrifice during the climactic battle. However, fans of Spike can rejoice, as he later appears in Angel, where he becomes a central character in the final season of that series. Returning to “Chosen,” it excels as a series finale, masterfully tying up numerous plot threads, delivering an emotional punch, and bringing back familiar faces, all while providing a fittingly epic conclusion to the series.
8
“Tabula Rasa”
Season 6, Episode 8 (2001)
The sixth season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer often draws mixed reactions from dedicated fans and critics alike, and while some criticisms are valid, it is frequently underestimated and misunderstood. This season delves into darker themes and explores the emotional turmoil of young adulthood, a necessary continuation after the devastating events of Season 5. The portrayal of characters grappling with a lack of direction in their lives resonates deeply with viewers. However, amidst the gloom, there are moments of levity and humor, exemplified by episodes like “Tabula Rasa.” This episode stands out as a self-contained masterpiece, employing the concept of memory loss to create comedic chaos while still contributing significantly to the overarching narrative. It serves as an effective follow-up to the unforgettable musical episode of Season 6, which will undoubtedly make its appearance in this ranking soon enough.
7
“Graduation Day: Part 2”
Season 3, Episode 22 (1999)
This ranking features four season finales, and it’s worth noting that the other finales from Season 1, Season 4, and Season 6 are also exemplary, deserving of honorable mentions for their outstanding contributions. However, none quite reach the level of excellence achieved by “Graduation Day: Part 2,” an episode that skillfully concludes the high school chapter of Buffy’s life and that of her friends. Following this finale, the narrative shifts to college, bringing about a new era fraught with the challenges and uncertainties of young adulthood. “Graduation Day: Part 2” stands as an exhilarating farewell to the high school setting, showcasing thrilling action and providing an exceptional climax that captivates the audience. Additionally, it serves as a poignant send-off for characters like Cordelia and Angel, particularly in his capacity as a main character on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, making it a truly memorable episode.
6
“Innocence”
Season 2, Episode 14 (1998)
The first season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer hinted at the series’ potential greatness, but it wasn’t until Season 2 that it truly began to shine. This season marked a significant maturation in storytelling and ambition, with the episode “Innocence” serving as a pivotal moment in the season’s narrative arc. In a dramatic twist, the character Angel transforms into Angelus after experiencing a moment of happiness, setting off a chain of events that defines the latter half of the season. In this episode, Angelus reunites with old friends, Spike and Drusilla, while ruthlessly tormenting Buffy, who is left devastated by the betrayal of someone she once loved deeply. Ultimately, by the episode’s end, Buffy rises to the occasion, wielding a rocket launcher and showcasing her strength in a moment that is both iconic and empowering.
5
“Hush”
Season 4, Episode 10 (1999)
While Buffy the Vampire Slayer is replete with supernatural elements, it is not always characterized by horror; however, episodes like “Hush” succeed in establishing a terrifying atmosphere. This episode introduces the chilling villains known as The Gentlemen, who cause the residents of Sunnydale to lose their voices, creating an eerie silence as they harvest hearts. The entire episode conveys a nightmarish tone, as it unfolds almost entirely without dialogue, aside from brief snippets at the beginning and end. Remarkably, “Hush” balances its horror with humor, showcasing the show’s unique ability to blend genres. This episode stands out not only as one of the series’ scariest but also as one of its funniest, as it cleverly develops the season-long narrative, particularly regarding Buffy’s relationship with her somewhat mundane boyfriend, Riley.
4
“The Gift”
Season 5, Episode 22 (2001)
“The Gift” stands out as a landmark episode for numerous reasons, particularly for being the 100th installment of the series. Crafted with the potential to serve as a bittersweet series finale, it features Buffy making the ultimate sacrifice to save the world—a powerful moment that resonates deeply with fans. Unlike her previous resurrection in Season 1’s “Prophecy Girl,” Buffy does not return to life immediately, adding a layer of gravity to her act of heroism. This sets the stage for Season 6, which explores the ramifications of her sacrifice. Additionally, the episode includes what many consider one of the most poignant quotes from Buffy the Vampire Slayer, when Buffy advises her sister Dawn, saying, “the hardest thing in this world… is to live in it… Be brave. Live. For me.” This quote encapsulates the emotional depth and thematic richness of the series.
3
“The Body”
Season 5, Episode 16 (2001)
For anyone who questions the assertion that Buffy the Vampire Slayer ranks among the greatest dramas in television history, “The Body” serves as compelling evidence. This episode delivers a raw and emotional exploration of grief that resonates deeply with viewers. It captures the profound shock and devastation felt by characters grappling with the loss of a loved one. Through its poignant portrayal of loss, “The Body” emphasizes that death can be a mundane occurrence, shattering the expectation that it should always be tied to supernatural events. This episode is a powerful reminder that grief is both brutal and authentic, showcasing the complexities of human emotion in a way that few works of fiction can replicate. While it may not be a lighthearted or frequently rewatchable episode, it remains an extraordinary piece of television.
2
“Once More, with Feeling”
Season 6, Episode 7 (2001)
In contrast to the emotional weight of “The Body,” “Once More, with Feeling” offers a vibrant and entertaining experience as the show’s iconic musical episode. This episode features an innovative premise where the residents of Sunnydale spontaneously break into song, providing a whimsical yet impactful narrative twist. Despite its lighthearted tone, the episode effectively advances the season’s drama, particularly revealing unsettling truths about Buffy’s resurrection that resonate deeply with the audience. The high-concept nature of “Once More, with Feeling” parallels “Hush” in its uniqueness, but it successfully delivers an engaging and memorable experience that stands as a highlight of the series. Even those who are not typically fond of musicals may find themselves captivated by this episode, as it brilliantly builds on the themes and character arcs established throughout the somewhat divisive sixth season.
1
“Becoming (Part 2)”
Season 2, Episode 22 (1998)
When considering shows that began in the 1990s and concluded in the 2000s, Buffy the Vampire Slayer stands out alongside The Sopranos as one of the very best. Just as the latter show showcased a stellar episode in its Season 2 finale, Buffy the Vampire Slayer also delivered an exceptional conclusion to its second season with “Becoming (Part 2).” This episode is pivotal in the overall narrative, providing a heart-wrenching conclusion to the season’s overarching storyline while establishing a sense of irrevocable change for the characters. While it may not possess the same level of despair as “The Body,” it evokes a different emotional response, serving more as a poignant tearjerker. The heightened melodrama aligns perfectly with the high school setting and the youthful experiences of the characters. Ultimately, “Becoming (Part 2)” solidified Buffy the Vampire Slayer as an all-time great series, erasing any doubts that earlier standout episodes were merely flukes. It serves as a textbook example of how to conclude an entire season of television effectively.
