The highly anticipated reunion between Josh Holloway and J.J. Abrams has resulted in the debut of the new show, Duster, which has impressively achieved a higher Rotten Tomatoes score than the last four seasons of the iconic series Lost. Holloway, known for his pivotal role as James “Sawyer” Ford—a charismatic conman with a heartbreaking backstory who survived the infamous crash of Oceanic Flight 815—is returning to the forefront of television. Fifteen years after the conclusion of Lost, Holloway, alongside co-creator J.J. Abrams, has launched Duster, where he portrays a getaway driver named Jim Ellis, teaming up with FBI agent Nina Hayes, played by Rachel Hilson, to dismantle a dangerous criminal syndicate.

According to Rotten Tomatoes, Duster has made a remarkable debut with an outstanding 93% score based on 14 reviews. This score surpasses the Tomatometer ratings of Lost‘s final four seasons, where season 3 garnered a score of 71%, season 4 achieved 89%, season 5 received 92%, and season 6 dropped to 69%. While the 93% score for Duster is currently based on a limited number of 14 reviews, it is expected to fluctuate as more critics weigh in. Additionally, a Popcornmeter score will be introduced once general audiences are able to access the show after its premiere on Max on May 15.

Implications of Duster’s Success for Future Series

Evaluating Duster as a Potential Successor to Lost for Josh Holloway

The impressive Tomatometer score of Duster suggests that it has the potential to rival the best seasons of Lost. With an average score of 93%, it only trails behind the first two seasons of Lost, which hold scores of 96% and 100%, respectively. These initial seasons represent the peak popularity of the series, and matching that level of quality would be a significant indicator of Duster‘s caliber. Notably, while seasons 3 and 6 of Lost have lower scores at 71% and 69%, they are still home to some of the most memorable episodes, making it a remarkable feat if Duster can deliver episodes that exceed those benchmarks in terms of engagement and storytelling.

Numerous Duster reviews highlight Holloway’s performance as one of the standout elements of the series, showcasing his ability to deliver a portrayal that is both captivating and thrilling. The excitement surrounding Holloway’s return to a leading role, especially in another J.J. Abrams production, is a significant factor for many viewers. Additionally, many reviews commend the performances of other cast members, particularly Rachel Hilson and Keith David. These strong performances are critical to the positive reception of Duster, indicating that it is already making a mark on critics and audiences alike.

Analyzing Duster’s Rotten Tomatoes Score: What It Means for Viewers

The Potential Impact of Duster on Josh Holloway’s Career Trajectory

As a devoted fan of Lost, I find it challenging to envision Duster matching or exceeding its predecessor’s legacy. Nevertheless, the promising debut score on Rotten Tomatoes along with the positive reviews suggest that this series could represent Holloway’s most significant project since Lost. Although he has previously taken on leading roles in USA Network’s Colony and had a recurring role in Yellowstone during its third and fourth seasons, Duster appears poised to elevate Holloway’s career trajectory, potentially opening doors to more leading roles in the near future.

Sources: Rotten Tomatoes