Lindsay Hubbard is facing a challenging situation as she navigates the complexities of Carl Radke’s romantic endeavors.

In an exclusive preview shared by E! News, fans get a glimpse into the drama of Summer House during the episode airing on April 9. In this episode, Carl openly discussed his eagerness to re-enter the dating scene following his breakup with Lindsay, which was marked by the end of their engagement the previous summer. He mentioned that he had gone on a date just a week prior, stirring up curiosity and concern among viewers.

However, despite Carl’s claims that his initial date with an unidentified woman did not go well, Lindsay confronted her former fiancé with allegations of infidelity. She suggested that he had been secretly involved with the same woman prior to their split in August 2023.

“So that was your first date with her?” Lindsay challenged Carl, adding, “because it’s come to my attention that you’ve been talking to her since last summer.” Her probing questions revealed the tension and unresolved feelings lingering between them. When Carl maintained that he had only begun communicating with the woman after their breakup, Lindsay pressed him further, demanding, “prove it. Show the receipts.” Ironically, Carl’s phone, supposedly containing the evidence, was upstairs charging, adding to the drama of the moment.