The captivating journey of this boy on The Masked Singer has unveiled an entirely new dimension of his capabilities, showcasing a remarkable evolution in his artistic expression.

During the highly anticipated episode of the Fox singing competition series that aired on April 16, a former ’90s teen sensation was eliminated. However, he left a lasting impression by demonstrating his impressive vocal abilities to both himself and the audience, proving that he still possesses the talent that once captivated fans.

“If you had told me that this little guy would still be standing here, I’d say, ‘You’re crazy,’ because I’ve never sang before,” the talented TV and film star—who performed under the guise of the season 13 character Paparazzo—confessed in a revealing video package. “And—big spoiler alert—this next song is the biggest hint to my identity yet,” he teased, leaving viewers eager to uncover the mystery.

Before unveiling his upcoming song, Paparazzo provided a significant clue about his true identity by featuring a surprise appearance from Boy Meets World alum Danielle Fishel, famously known as Topanga from the cherished ’90s sitcom. This nostalgic reference served as a delightful nod to fans of the era.

With great enthusiasm, the mystery celebrity took to the stage and delivered a heartfelt rendition of TLC‘s iconic hit “Unpretty.” His powerful performance not only showcased his vocal prowess but also resonated with many viewers, eliciting a wave of emotional responses from the audience.

Following his performance, the judges were granted 30 seconds to engage Paparazzo in a series of probing questions, seeking to unravel the enigma of his identity. One of the most revealing questions posed was whether he had ever starred in a hit TV show. His confident response? “Oh yeah!” This admission only deepened the intrigue surrounding his identity, leaving fans speculating about the talented individual behind the mask.