The thrilling news has just emerged for devoted fans of the often-overlooked Rock and Roll Hall of Fame candidates, particularly Warren Zevon and Bad Company, who have finally been honored with induction into the prestigious class of 2025. This recognition not only celebrates their lasting contributions to the music industry but also provides a sense of vindication for their loyal supporters who have campaigned tirelessly for years.

On the flip side, Phish aficionados received disappointing news, as the beloved jam-rock band was notably absent from this year’s inductee list. This omission has sparked discussions and surprises among their vast fanbase, who passionately believe that Phish deserves a place among the honored.

Founded in 1983 in Vermont, Phish has carved out a distinctive musical identity, blending elements of progressive rock, jazz, and funk. Their live performances are characterized by extended, mind-bending improvisations that often last over twenty minutes, contributing to their reputation for creating an electrifying atmosphere filled with spontaneity and creativity. The band consists of four incredibly talented musicians: Trey Anastasio (guitar and lead vocals), Page McConnell (keyboards and vocals), Mike Gordon (bass and vocals), and Jon Fishman (drums and vocals). Phish not only meets the criteria for induction through their consistently high-demand tours but also offers a sound that is uniquely their own. Their performances are famously unpredictable, with the band never repeating the same setlist, exemplified by their remarkable achievement of thirteen consecutive sellouts at Madison Square Garden, known as “The Baker’s Dozen,” where no song was repeated.

Watch Phish Perform ‘Blaze On’

The Rock Hall describes the experience of attending a Phish concert as unparalleled, stating, “There is nothing like the pure freedom and joy of a Phish concert—a powerful communal moment often likened to a religious experience, a transcendent moment.” This description encapsulates the essence of what makes Phish’s performances so special, as fans come together to share in an unforgettable musical journey.

Despite topping the fan votes for this year’s nominees by a staggering margin of over 50,000 votes, Phish was unfortunately left out of the induction festivities. This major oversight raises the question: How could such a beloved band be overlooked?

In a surprising twist, Billy Idol, who ranked third in total fan voting with more than 260,000 votes, also faced a similar snub, failing to secure a spot in this year’s inductee list. Meanwhile, other artists, such as The White Stripes, made the cut despite receiving fewer votes, while The Black Crowes also missed the mark. The fan vote breakdown reveals the perplexing nature of this year’s selections:

Phish: 329,281 votes
Bad Company: 280,725 votes
Billy Idol: 260,416 votes
Cyndi Lauper: 236,960 votes
Joe Cocker: 233,495 votes
Soundgarden: 233,205 votes
Chubby Checker: 203,092 votes
The Black Crowes: 165,249 votes
Mariah Carey: 137,993 votes
Joy Division + New Order: 120,346 votes
The White Stripes: 110,511 votes
Outkast: 108,073 votes
Oasis: 99,381 votes
Maná: 34,506 votes

Read More: When Phish Staged ‘The Great Went’

So, how exactly are these fan votes calculated? Rather than allowing each fan to cast their vote for their preferred artist individually, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame consolidates the top five nominees onto a single ballot, which only represents one of the 1,200 total ballots cast. This voting structure diminishes the impact of individual fan preferences, which may explain why beloved artists like Billy Idol, The Black Crowes, and Phish were ultimately overlooked this year.

In a similar vein, back in 2020, despite winning the fan vote, the Dave Matthews Band was also denied induction into the Rock Hall. However, they eventually received their due recognition and were inducted in 2024. Therefore, while this snub may seem disheartening for Phish fans at this moment, it is essential to remember that this is not necessarily the end of the road for them, as they continue to blaze their own unique trail in the music scene. Perhaps it is time for the Rock Hall to consider updating their voting metrics to better reflect fan sentiment.