If you are a fan of the captivating dynamic between Xaden and Rhysand, you’ll want to dive into a book that subverts one of the most cherished recent fantasy tropes. The genre of romantasy has surged in popularity, thanks in large part to the influence of BookTok, leading to some series and standalone novels, such as Rebecca Yarros’ The Empyrean Series and Sarah J. Maas’ A Court Of Thorns & Roses, receiving heightened attention. However, there are numerous underrated romantasy titles that truly deserve the spotlight, especially those that incorporate the beloved tropes that BookTok enthusiasts have come to adore.

BookTok has played a pivotal role in popularizing fantasy series featuring strong female protagonists, detailed world-building, and an engaging blend of fantasy and romance. The degree of romantic intensity often influences popularity, yet some well-loved romantasy series lack explicit adult content while still generating discussions across BookTok and other literary communities. The “shadow daddy” trope consistently attracts readers, but one standout series takes this trope in an intriguing new direction, adding depth and complexity to the narrative.

Discover How 2024’s Anathema Delivers a Refreshing Twist on the “Shadow Daddy” Trope in Romantasy

Explore Shadow Daddy Characters in Major BookTok Series and Their Impact

Anathema by Keri Lake is an exceptional choice for fantasy enthusiasts who crave the infamous “shadow daddy” trope, a hallmark of various popular romantasy series. This trope typically features a love interest with shadow manipulation abilities and a brooding, morally ambiguous personality. Frequently portrayed as a supernatural being, the shadow daddy is often much older than the female protagonist, adorned with tattoos that enhance his intimidating presence, which softens in the presence of his beloved.

Numerous fantasy works incorporate a “shadow daddy” character within their narratives. The two most prominent examples are Xaden Riorson from Yarros’ work and Rhysand from Maas’ series. Xaden’s signet in Fourth Wing and Rhysand’s role as the High Lord of Night exemplify this trope, which is also evident in other popular titles, including Quicksilver, Shadow and Bone, and the Kindred’s Curse Saga. Each of these narratives showcases unique interpretations of the archetype, but Anathema stands out as it redefines this trope in ways that few other series dare to explore.

Anathema Redefines the Shadow Daddy Trope in a Unique and Engaging Way

Meet Anathema’s Female Heroine Who Commands Shadow Powers

The female protagonist of Anathema, Maevyth Bronwick, embodies the essence of the “shadow daddy” trope in a surprising twist, effectively flipping this classic fantasy trope on its head. According to Goodreads, Maevyth possesses the extraordinary ability to break the curse of Witch Knell, a power that makes her a target for the magehood of her former home, eager to eliminate her. This dark power, combined with her morally complex character throughout the narrative, allows Maevyth to resonate strongly with the archetype traditionally reserved for male characters, even as her counterpart also exhibits elements of this trope.

Zevander Rydainn, known as the Scorpion, is an assassin whose name reflects his blunt and lethal demeanor, creating the classic tension of enemies-to-lovers in Anathema. However, Maevyth’s struggle with her abilities and her acceptance of her dark side provide a new interpretation of the “shadow daddy” concept. In romantasy, female characters often do not get the chance to delve into their darker aspects, making Maevyth’s journey a refreshing departure and illustrating how these elements drive the central narrative forward. Ultimately, Keri Lake’s fantasy novel brings the “shadow daddy” trope from the shadows into a new, enlightening perspective.