West Wilson sparked a heated discussion among his Summer House cast members regarding the details of his new relationship.

During part one of the season 10 reunion, the 31-year-old disclosed the true timeline of his controversial relationship with Amanda Batula, 34, who announced the end of her four-year marriage to Kyle Cooke on January 19. According to West, he made the first move on the Jersey native at the end of February, coinciding with the conclusion of his on-again-off-again relationship with her best friend, Ciara Miller.

“When we were out, I kind of looked at Amanda,” West admitted to host Andy Cohen on the May 26 Bravo episode. “And I was like, ‘Am I f–king crazy or is there a little something going on here?'”

In fact, it was after a group brunch on March 1 with fellow castmates Kyle, Jesse Solomon, and Ben Waddell that West and Amanda shared their first kiss—unbeknownst to their Hamptons friend group—the timing of which Ciara remarked was “so funny” considering the texts she had received from Amanda at the time, insisting West was nothing more than a friend.