In this week’s edition of Loudwire’s Chuck’s Fight Club, we are comparing two Metallica albums that represent significant “firsts.” And Justice for All marked the first album featuring Jason Newsted on bass after the tragic passing of Cliff Burton. Meanwhile, Death Magnetic was the first album where Robert Trujillo contributed creatively after joining the band. Which debut was more impactful for these bassists?

On one hand, we have Metallica’s And Justice for All, released in the aftermath of Cliff Burton’s untimely death in a bus accident. This album is often noted for the subdued bass sound of Jason Newsted, yet it remains a classic with standout tracks like “One,” “Harvester of Sorrow,” and “Eye of the Beholder,” as well as the deeper cut “Blackened.”

On the other hand, Death Magnetic represents a new era with Robert Trujillo. Producer Bob Rock had played bass on the previous St. Anger album, but Death Magnetic was Trujillo’s first album as an official member of the band. Released in 2008, this album was praised for its quality, featuring tracks such as “The Day That Never Comes,” “My Apocalypse,” “All Nightmare Long,” and “Broken, Beat and Scarred.”

As is customary in Chuck’s Fight Club battles, Loudwire Nights host Chuck Armstrong will introduce this matchup during the 8PM hour of Monday’s show. Arguments for both albums will be presented on Tuesday and Wednesday, allowing listeners to rank their preferences. On Friday, votes will be counted, and the album with the higher ranking will be highlighted in a special Loudwire Nights rock block during the 8PM hour.

READ MORE: Enter Now To Win a Trip + Interview Metallica in Kansas City!

A reminder that Loudwire Nights with Chuck Armstrong airs nightly starting at 7PM ET. You can listen anytime from anywhere right here or by downloading the Loudwire app.

Below is a gallery showcasing the 12 longest-running metal bands that have never disbanded.